Other Free Encyclopedias » Law Library - American Law and Legal Information » Notable Trials and Court Cases - 1833 to 1882

Wyatt Earp Trial: 1881 - A Mysterious Stage Coach Robbery, Trouble Brewing, Shootout, The Hearing, Aftermath, Suggestions For Further Reading

tombstone city marshal cowboys

Defendants: Wyatt Earp, Virgil Earp, Morgan Earp, John "Doc" Holliday
Crime Charged: Murder
Chief Defense Lawyer: Thomas Fitch
Chief Prosecutor: Lyttleton Price
Judge: Wells Spicer
Place: Tombstone, Arizona
Date of Trial: October 31-November 29, 1881
Verdict: Not guilty

SIGNIFICANCE: The month-long trial—actually a preliminary hearing—made possible an American legend. Nearly every American, and millions in foreign lands, knows about Wyatt Earp, the heroic marshal who brought law and order to a score of Kansas cow towns before wiping out a gang of savage rustlers in the shootout at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona. Unfortunately, there is little truth in the legend. If this hearing were conducted under different circumstances, Earp would be remembered as just another shady, if not totally criminal, frontier gunslinger.

In Tombstone, Arizona, a mining town, "cowboy" was synonymous with "rustler." There were a lot of rustlers in surrounding Cochise County, and most of the cattlemen, if not actually thieves, were the rustlers' customers. Tombstone citizens, most of them Union sympathizers during the Civil War, blamed the "cowboys," largely Confederate sympathizers, for every crime. Tombstone citizens had been discussing a vigilance committee to rid the county of undesirables, meaning all the cowboys. The proposed leader of the committee was Wyatt Earp.

Earp was by his own account a hero who had tamed many cow towns in Kansas. Actually, he was a former horse thief and buffalo hunter who had been fired from the Wichita police force for corruption and literally run out of town. He came to Dodge City and got a job on its four-man police force. In Dodge, he spent most of his time gambling with cowboys flush with back pay from the cattle drives. When the cattle boom there ended, he and his brothers moved west to gamble with the silver miners. Earp told everyone about his gunfighting skills and secured a faro dealership in return for protecting the staff of Tombstone's Oriental Saloon soon after he arrived in 1876.

Wyatt and Morgan Earp worked for the Wells Fargo Stage Coach company, but Wyatt wanted to be sheriff of Cochise County. So, although Wyatt was the hero of the "law and order" faction in Tombstone, the Earps also tried to stay on good terms with the cowboys. That may be why, when a prominent rustler, Curly Bill Brocius, shot and killed City Marshal Fred White, Virgil Earp, deputy city marshal, swore it was an accident. It was a most improbable accident:for it to happen, White would have had to be reaching for a cocked revolver pointing at his chest. Coincidentally, White's "accidental" death made Virgil acting city marshal.

The incumbent sheriff, Johnny Behan, was Wyatt Earp's rival in love as well as politics. Wyatt had begun squiring around Behan's mistress, Josie Marcus, an actress and department store heiress. Earp kept his own common-law wife, Mattie, confined to their home.

Wyatt Earp, known for his participation in the shootout at O.K. Corral, Tombstone, Arizona. (Archive Photos) Wyatt Earp, known for his participation in the shootout at O.K. Corral, Tombstone, Arizona. (Archive Photos)

Wynehamer v. the People - The Temperance Movement, Prohibition And Property [next] [back] The Whitman Massacre Trial: 1850 - Five Cayuse Braves Arrested, The Trial Begins, Passionate Closing Arguments, The Sentence Is Death

User Comments

Your email address will be altered so spam harvesting bots can't read it easily.
Hide my email completely instead?

Cancel or

Vote down Vote up

over 10 years ago

WOW!!! I had no idea as to the truth of Wyatt Earp. This was really enlightening to say the least.

Vote down Vote up

almost 10 years ago

Your portrayal, is crafty,and missing information. You have no sites posted as to where you got your information. You should really read more about him before you write a biography about him. I hate Revisionist history. You Revisionists are the problem with america. History isn't what you say it is. History is what happened. You achieve nothing by telling falsehoods.

Vote down Vote up

almost 10 years ago

Obviously, this author has an axe to grind against Earp. He doesn't cite sources and engages in the same wild-eyed reporting he accuses others of.

Obviously, he's not someone that cares for American Legends, even obviously flawed American Legends.

This author's version is at LEAST as inaccurate as any biography rendered about Wyatt Earp. You really have to wonder about the author's motivation.

Sadly, he sounds like another goofball who doesn't like american western legend and doesn't really understand the period at all.

Frankly, he sounds like a sad, little man, that believes tearing down others will elevate him. Sadly, it won't, because this author is clearly a VERY little man and a man of limited intellect and research skills.

Vote down Vote up

almost 3 years ago

The article is reasonably accurate although a bit skewed until the last two paragraphs, where the author fully reveals a strong bias.

There are absolutely NO contemporary records that show Wyatt and Josephine had a relationship while in Tombstone. In fact, Wyatt was living with Mattie Blaylock until he left town after Morgan's murder. While addicted to laudanum, a commonly used opiate and painkiller, there is NO evidence that she was "confined" to their home. After kicking Johnny Behan out, Josephine rented her house in mid-summer of 1881 to Dr. George Goodfellow.

It's certain that Josephine and Wyatt knew each other: Johnny Behan and Wyatt Earp both had offices on the second floor of the Crystal Palace Saloon. When Josephine left Tombstone on March 25, 1882, shortly after Wyatt rode for New Mexico, she traveled under the name of either Mrs. J. C. Earp or Mrs. Wyatt Earp. You can infer that they may have had a relationship, but they were never reported in public together.

Lastly, Josephine wasn't by any stretch of the imagination an actress and department store "heiress." A rudimentary amount of research into her life immediately casts doubt on her claims to being from a wealthy family. Her parents were living with their son-in-law and daughter in 1880, as documented in the U.S. Census.